Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney delivered a blunt rebuke to President Donald Trump during a high-stakes Oval Office meeting Tuesday, declaring that “Canada is not for sale” after Trump once again floated the idea of acquiring the country as the United States’ 51st state.
The remark came moments after Trump described the border between the U.S. and Canada as “artificial” and suggested that the two nations could form “a wonderful marriage,” despite repeated rejections from Canadian leadership and the public.
“As you know from real estate, there are some places that are never for sale,” Carney told Trump, invoking the language of property ownership in response to the president’s comments. “Canada is not for sale. It will never be for sale. But the opportunity is in the partnership and what we can build together.”
See also: Trump Offers Undocumented Immigrants $1,000 to Deport Themselves—Yes, Really
Trump Pushes “Annexation Lite,” Carney Pushes Back
While Trump downplayed the conversation as hypothetical—“unless somebody wants to discuss it,” he said—his continued references to acquiring Canada have injected uncertainty into an already strained bilateral relationship.
“I’m a very artistic person,” Trump told reporters. “When you get rid of that artificially drawn line… it’s beautiful when it’s together.”
Carney’s response marked the sharpest on-the-record rejection of the idea yet. In previous weeks, he had warned Canadians that Trump is “trying to break us so that America can own us.”
Trump, unfazed, doubled down later in the meeting:
“Time will tell. It’s only time. But I say never say never.”
See also: Trump Wanted to «Break Us»: Mark Carney Leads Liberals to Fourth Term in Canada
Trade Hostilities Simmer Beneath the Surface
The meeting also highlighted ongoing tensions over trade. Carney, newly elected and critical of Trump’s economic policies, insisted that Canada would only negotiate “on our terms.” Trump, meanwhile, confirmed that no progress had been made toward lifting the 25% tariff he imposed on Canadian goods not covered by the USMCA trade agreement. The U.S. president again cited fentanyl trafficking and migration as justifications for the tariffs.
Carney called that a “bigger discussion,” while emphasizing Canada’s retaliatory tariffs—$21 billion worth—on a wide array of American goods, from orange juice and motorcycles to paper products and cosmetics.
Despite the diplomatic friction, Trump insisted the relationship was stable.
“Regardless of anything, we’re going to be friends with Canada,” he said.
But his own social media post earlier in the day painted a different picture.
“We don’t need their Cars, we don’t need their Energy, we don’t need their Lumber, we don’t need ANYTHING they have, other than their friendship, which hopefully we will always maintain,” Trump posted. “They, on the other hand, need EVERYTHING from us!”
See also: Trump Wants a 100% Tariff on Foreign Films—Here’s What That Could Do to Hollywood
A New Era in U.S.-Canada Relations?
Carney’s meeting with Trump marked the first time the two leaders met in person. Unlike his predecessor Justin Trudeau—whom Trump often mocked and sidelined—Carney enters with no personal history with the U.S. president, but plenty of political distance. His campaign was partially fueled by anti-Trump rhetoric and a promise to redefine Canada’s global partnerships without relying on the United States.
“Our previous relationship with the U.S. is over,” Carney said during his victory speech. “We must fundamentally reimagine our economy.”
Trump, however, dismissed the idea that Carney’s defiant tone would impact negotiations. “No, not at all,” he said when asked by reporters if the prime minister’s comments made diplomacy more difficult.
What Comes Next
The White House has not scheduled any follow-up negotiations with Canadian officials. Tariff enforcement remains unchanged, and Trump has continued to threaten a 100% import tax on foreign-made films, a move that would impact Canada’s substantial entertainment industry.
Carney, for his part, made it clear that his administration will continue to reject overtures toward annexation or integration with the United States.
“It’s always important to distinguish want from reality,” he said last week. “What the Canadian people clearly have stated, virtually without exception, is this will never, never happen.”
