The first day of the 2025 Conclave was supposed to be a solemn occasion, setting the tone for the election of the next pope. However, the atmosphere was far from calm. Several events took place that raised eyebrows and fueled speculation, making the day far more tense than it should have been. These seemingly small moments, caught on microphones and shared on social media, might hint at deeper currents within the Vatican’s corridors of power. Let’s break down these moments that have sparked controversy and leave us questioning what’s truly at stake.
First Day of 2025 Conclave: All the Controversies
The “Double Best Wishes” to Cardinal Parolin
One of the first sparks of intrigue came during the Pro Eligendo Romano Pontifice Mass when Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re, the Dean of the College of Cardinals, exchanged the sign of peace with Cardinal Pietro Parolin. In that brief interaction, Re was overheard saying, “Auguri e doppi,” or “Double best wishes,” as they embraced. While it may have seemed like a harmless gesture, the comment immediately caught the attention of many. The remark, which was broadcasted live to millions around the world, quickly became the subject of widespread speculation.
Read also: Who is Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle? LGBTQ+ Community Favorite to Become the Next Pope
Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re was overheard telling Parolin, the Papal frontrunner: “Best wishes. Double best wishes.”
Latest 👉 https://t.co/XrKrfe2aFB pic.twitter.com/vlqzG7kpgM
— Sky News (@SkyNews) May 7, 2025
Some observers believe this was more than just a friendly greeting. They suspect it could be a subtle acknowledgment of Parolin’s dual role in the conclave: one as an elector and the other as a key papal candidate. As the Vatican’s Secretary of State, Parolin holds immense influence and is widely regarded as a frontrunner for the papacy. The “double” wishes might hint at an unspoken endorsement for his candidacy, with Re signaling his support for the diplomatic heavyweight. Others suggest that the comment could be acknowledging Re’s own transition out of the voting process, as the 91-year-old cardinal is no longer eligible to cast a ballot in the conclave. Regardless of the interpretation, the exchange has stirred conversation, adding a layer of intrigue to an already charged atmosphere.
A Controversial Homily
As the homily was delivered during the Mass, another moment added to the growing tension. Cardinal Re’s sermon focused on themes of unity, love, and pastoral responsibility, drawing on biblical passages and the teachings of past popes. But there was one striking omission: Pope Francis’ name was never mentioned. In a moment that many expected to honor the outgoing pope, Re’s decision not to mention Francis has raised questions.
Read also: The Murky “Exorcism” Prayer Cardinals Perform Before Every Conclave Explained
While some argue that it was simply a standard practice to maintain neutrality before the conclave’s official voting, others see it as a deliberate move to signal a transition in leadership. Could this be an indication of a change in direction within the Church? Was it a subtle signal that the electors were preparing for a new kind of leadership?
Cardinal Robert Sarah’s Absence: A Silent Protest?
The absence of Cardinal Robert Sarah, a prominent conservative figure, added another layer of mystery to the Conclave’s first day. Sarah, known for his traditionalist views, was expected to attend the Pro Eligendo Romano Pontifice Mass. However, he was notably absent, sparking widespread speculation about the reasons behind his nonattendance.
Read also: Can a Cardinal Refuse to Be Pope? Here’s What Happens if the Conclave Gets a ‘No’
Some believe his absence was due to health issues, while others wonder if it was a deliberate choice to distance himself from the proceedings.
The first day of the 2025 Conclave was far from routine. From the whispered “double wishes” to the omission of Pope Francis’ name and Cardinal Sarah’s conspicuous absence, the events set a tone of secrecy and uncertainty. Whether these moments reflect deeper political maneuverings or are simply coincidences, one thing is clear: the Conclave is already shaping up to be a highly charged affair, and the outcome may be influenced by far more than just the ballots cast.