The Vatican has made a highly controversial decision regarding the funeral of Pope Francis—and it brings back one of the most painful chapters in the Catholic Church’s modern history. At the center of the storm is US Cardinal Roger Mahony, a retired Archbishop from Los Angeles with a deeply criticized past. While the funeral is meant to be a sacred moment of unity and remembrance, the decision to give Mahony a ceremonial role has divided both the faithful and critics of the Church alike.
US Cardinal Mahony and the abuse scandal that rocked American Catholic Church
US Cardinal Roger Mahony served as Archbishop of Los Angeles from 1985 to 2011. During this time, he became a central figure in one of the most devastating clergy sexual abuse scandals in U.S. history. Investigations revealed that Mahony and other Church officials systematically shielded priests accused of sexual abuse by transferring them to other parishes rather than reporting them to law enforcement. These actions allowed predators to continue harming victims, often without consequence.
In 2007, the Archdiocese of Los Angeles paid a historic $660 million to settle claims from over 500 abuse survivors. Despite this massive payout and years of public outrage, Mahony remained within the Church’s ranks. In 2013, his successor, Archbishop José Gomez, relieved him of all public and administrative duties—but Mahony was never formally removed from the priesthood. The Vatican never imposed additional penalties. To this day, he is considered a “priest in good standing.”
What did Pope Francis say about Mahony’s past?
Pope Francis, known for his vocal support of abuse survivors and efforts to reform Church practices, never publicly addressed Mahony’s role in the Los Angeles scandal. This silence has raised eyebrows over the years, especially as Francis took stronger stances against cover-ups in other parts of the world. While he has pushed for transparency and accountability, Mahony’s continued presence in Church affairs—even in ceremonial capacities—remains a sore point for many observers.
Mahony’s Controversial Role in Pope Francis’ Funeral Rites
Now, in a move that has reignited fierce criticism, Cardinal Mahony has been chosen to help close Pope Francis’ coffin and oversee part of the burial rites. According to the Vatican, this decision is based on his seniority as a cardinal priest. However, many argue that symbolic moments like these are not just about tradition—they send powerful messages to the public.
Survivors of abuse and advocacy groups have expressed outrage, calling the decision tone-deaf and harmful to the Church’s credibility. For them, seeing Mahony perform this sacred duty feels like a painful erasure of the trauma suffered by victims under his watch.
What Does the Coffin-Sealing Ritual Involve?
- Read also: Did a Demon Reveal Itself to Pope Francis? A Sinister Theory Haunts the Internet After His Death
The role assigned to US Cardinal Mahony is part of an important Catholic ritual following the death of a pope. After a period of mourning and lying in state, a ceremony is held to seal the pope’s coffin. This involves placing symbolic items inside the wooden casket: a document summarizing the pope’s life, coins minted during his pontificate, and other elements reflecting his time as the leader of the Church.
The sealed coffin is then transferred to the Basilica of Santa Maria Maggiore for final burial. While the ritual is steeped in tradition and reverence, the choice of who participates in it inevitably becomes a matter of public and symbolic significance—especially when that person has a controversial history.
For many, the funeral of Pope Francis was supposed to mark the end of an era defined by openness and reform. Instead, it’s now shadowed by the inclusion of a figure who symbolizes everything the Church has tried to leave behind.
